I am thinking through it and had another variation on the idea. Taking into account @janitor comment, I think it could steer away the initiative away from a general money exchange and transfer service while still providing the community service of raising awareness about both the SAFE project, fund related community initiatives, and grow the number of enthusiasts, and establish a positive feedback loop in increasing the confidence in the community which eventually should increase the value of MaidSafeCoins. Let me know what you think.
So the idea is to create a community investment fund in MaidSafeCoins at an address publicly linked to some community member in order to establish public accountability for management of funds (initially me). These MaidSafeCoins will be sold to newcomers interested in the project. The proceed of the sale in BTC will go directly and entirely to a community project. The choice of the project to support is left to the buyer. The list of projects is democratically decided by the community. Current holders of MaidSafeCoins are invited to donate MaidSafeCoins to the fund. All transactions are public but neither MaidSafeCoin donators or buyers need to reveal their identity.
What is in it for everyone?
MaidSafeCoin donators
- Invest in community projects directly in MaidSafeCoins
- Grow the community and the number of potential traders on exchanges
- Increase the confidence in the community and the market value of MaidSafeCoins
For example, let’s say a big holder (>100,000$) decides to invest 1% (>1000$) in the fund and the average value of MaidSafeCoins over a month increases by 5%, that would generate a 3.95% return on investment (ex: (100,000 - 1,000) * 0.05 = 3,950$). That also works collectively for all MaidSafeCoin holders: if they were all to invest 1%, regardless of the amount they hold and see an increase of 5% in the value of MaidSafeCoins, everyone wins. Obviously, given the lack of liquidity of the market that gain cannot be realized on a short term. However, if it introduces a more steady and consistent growth in the value of MaidSafeCoins it makes the investment less risky than the all or nothing bet of waiting for the network to launch. So far, we have seen a factor of 4X between the lowest and highest value of MaidSafeCoins. If a positive feedback loop can be introduced through community investments and @dallyshalla is right in his analysis of the undervaluation of MaidSafeCoins by a factor of 30-50x (I would like to see the analysis behind these numbers…) then there is ample room for growth.
Maybe we could do an initial crowd-funding round for the donation round and only go forward if at least 30% of MaidSafeCoin addresses donate 0.01% of their holdings to the fund. That would avoid the initial perverse incentive of taking a wait and see approach to profit from others investing in the community without having to do it oneself. The initial amount of the fund should be small enough to be almost negligible if everything go wrong while still being big enough to support initiative that could have a significant impact on the community.
Community innovators
- Get official endorsement from the community
- Get exposure to new comers
- Obtain funds for initiative
Community members
- Have a stake in the direction of the community by choosing which projects should be supported
We would have to decide how to grant voting rights to community members. Maybe grant it to forum members that obtained the ‘Regular’ badge? We would also have to decide on a platform for voting, maybe Loomio would be adequate? It would be good if we could tie the identity on Loomio to the identity on the forum in order to ensure that both are the same person.
Newcomers (MaidSafeCoin buyers)
- Buy first coins from a reputable source
- Support a community project at the same time
How could that work?
Donations to the Fund
Kickstarter-style initial funding round where the funds are returned if less than X% of addresses do not send at least Y% within a time period. For example, if less than 50% of addresses do not provide 0.01% of their holdings to the fund, everyone gets reimbursed.
Subsequent rounds would see the % of addresses and % of holdings contributed adjusted from community feedback.
Vetting of projects
Every month, regular community members that obtained the ‘Regular’ badge on the forum can propose to add or remove projects from the vetted list during a one week period. If at least 2 other members support the proposition, the week after, members have one week to vote for or against the change. A majority wins.
To be added, a project must have a BTC address that has been shown to be under the control of one of the project members to receive funds, a public website that explains the project, and the current realizations.
Buying MaidSafeCoins from the Fund
To buy MaidSafeCoins, a buyer opens a trade by posting on a special page in the forum (or any other platform) a trade order, with the current exchange rate MaidSafeCoins/BTC, the amount of MaidSafeCoins being bought, and the corresponding value in BTC, as well as the project supported.
He then sends the exact amount of BTC to one of the vetted project and produce a transaction for that amount on block chain.info or something else.
Once the transaction has been verified by the fund manager, the corresponding MaidSafeCoins are sent to the sender BTC address. The fund manager produces a post on the forum that shows both the BTC transaction to one of the projects, and the corresponding MaidSafeCoins transaction to the buyer.
Comments
We are truly in Bitcoin land with this proposal. The fact that every transaction can be verified by anyone in the community, both for MaidSafeCoins and Bitcoins, allows anyone to ensure that people handling money act in the community interest and according to the rules defined above. Its exciting to see it possible and I have not seen anyone else do something like it before!
Since the destination of the funds is not arbitrary anymore and is limited to community vetted projects, I don’t think the service qualifies as a money exchange service anymore since funds cannot be routed through the service in arbitrary ways.
The amount of resources that can be made available to the community this way is potentially huge depending on the willingness of investors to use the process to increase their investment value. The amount of available resources becomes proportional to the market capitalization of MaidSafeCoins.
It might have a net effect of distributing the coins more broadly in the community and decrease the % everyone holds, so if seen purely from a MaidSafeCoin perspective, an investor could have the impression that it is a net loss. However, since MaidSafeCoins are highly speculative and have no intrinsic value (contrary to the SafeCoins that are going to be used by the network), it is their value in USD that is important and as long as it grows faster than the % contributed to the fund that should be a net win.
Let me know what you think. If that proposition turns out to be popular enough I’ll try to clarify it further, test how it could be implemented, and come back with a more official version. I think it should be more fun and have more impact than me trying my teeth at day trading ;-).